Brien Roche has tried hundreds of jury cases to conclusion. He has had multiple million-dollar verdicts and settlements. He has authored three well-recognized legal texts, two of which deal exclusively with Virginia law. One of those legal texts is Objections. This is a book outlining how objections may be made at trial and in the course of a legal proceeding. It is published by the Virginia Law Foundation, which is the continuing legal education arm of the Virginia State Bar.  Virginia Torts Case Finder is an 800-plus page compendium of Virginia tort law. Law 101 is a layperson’s guide to the law. It is published by Source Books. It has sold over 30,000 copies. Schedule a consultation with our auto accident attorney to learn how we can help you navigate a rear-end car accident claim.

Liability Still Needs to be Proven With a Rear-End Car Accident

A rear-end car accident or a rear-ender creates what lawyers call a “prima facie case”. What that means is that the fact that the defendant struck the plaintiff from the rear makes out the basic elements of a claim that the plaintiff has against that defendant. That claim, however, can be rebutted. 

What Are Common Defenses in a Rear-End Car Accident Case?

There are a number of potential defenses that the striking vehicle may assert. They may claim that the plaintiff stopped suddenly for no reason. They may claim that the plaintiff’s taillights didn’t work. They may claim that they were forced into the plaintiff’s vehicle by the vehicle behind them.

If the plaintiff’s vehicle stalled suddenly in the roadway creating an obstruction, that potentially could be a defense. Motorists should maintain a distance of at least one vehicle length for every 10 miles per hour being traveled. If a motorist has done that and the vehicle in front stalls out and stops suddenly, is the striking vehicle at fault? Probably, but that stalling may add a complication to the case. It could be a defense to any claim for personal injury. That potentially could be a jury issue depending on how close the defendant was to the plaintiff’s vehicle, the speed of the vehicles, and other potential circumstances.

Sudden Emergency in Rear-End Car Accident Cases

Sometimes, the plaintiff may claim the existence of what is called a “sudden emergency”. Most often, that is a sudden medical emergency. That sudden medical emergency may be the reason why they stopped suddenly on the roadway. The defendant may also sometimes use that as a defense. They may claim that the reason that they couldn’t stop was because of a sudden medical emergency.

Sudden medical emergencies are governed by very specific rules. Typically, if it’s a medical condition that the party was aware of and they didn’t exercise reasonable caution in terms of driving, they may still be negligent.

Va. Code § 46.2-816 says that a driver shall not follow another motor vehicle more closely than is reasonable. If that statute is violated and the defendant then has a sudden medical emergency, the emergency may explain why the rear-end crash occurred, but it probably is not a defense.

×